JULIAN RHODES' DREAM ORGANS
PROPOSALS WHICH REMAINED ON PAPER



St. James Picadilly and St. Martin-in-the-Fields, London
1980s Frobenius proposals



ST. JAMES, PICCADILLY

An organ was built by Renautus Harris in 1685 for the Royal Chapel in Whitehall, and was given to St. James's in 1691. Its disposition was:

Great: 8.8.4.4.3.2.IV.(V?).8.4.V
Choir: 8.8.4.4.2.8
Echo: 8.4.II.8

It was rebuilt and enlarged by Bishop in 1851 and Rothwell in the 1920s/30s, by which time it had a romantic specification of 35 stops as follows:

Great: 16.8.8.8.8.8.4.4.III.8.4
Swell: 16.8.8.8.8.4.2.III.16.8.8.4
Choir:  8.8.8.8.4.8.8
Pedal: 16.16.16.8.16

In the 1980s an appeal was launched for a new organ by Frobenius, to cost £175,000. The publicity leaflet stated:

The visual effect of the case has been spoilt by extensions and the interior of the organ, much altered, is now beyond repair. The instrument recently fell silent and is unplayable. However, the splendid case could easily be restored and much of the original pipework is well worth preserving.

The new organ was to be "modelled closely on Harris's original scheme and incorporating all his pipework that survives. It should be housed entirely within the old casework." Though the proposed stoplist may have taken the Harris disposition as a starting-point, it deviates far from it into the 1980s Eurpean mainstream, with a 16ft. Dulcian, celestes and a 32ft. Bassoon included in its 39 stops. But it is attractively characterful and coherent.


GREAT     
    16       Bourdon         
     8       Open Diapason
     8       Stopt Diapason
     4       Principal
     4       Flute
    2 2/3    Twelfth
     2       Fifteenth
    IV       Fourniture
     V       Cornet
     8       Trumpet
     4       Clarion
 
CHAIRE    
     8       Stopt Diapason
     4       Principal
     4       Flute
     2       Gemshorn
    1 1/3    Larigot
     1       Twenty-Second
    II       Sesquialtera
    III      Scharf
    16       Dulcian
     8       Crumhorn
             Tremulant
 
ECHO
     8       Bourdon
     8       Salicional
     8       Unda Maris
     4       Flute
    2 2/3    Nazard
     2       Fifteenth
    1 3/5    Tierce
    II       Cymbal
     8       Trumpet
             Tremulant
 
PEDAL
    16       Subbass
     8       Principal
     8       Flute               transmission from Great
     4       Octave              transmission from Great
    III      Mixture
    32       Bassoon
    16       Trumpet
     8       Trumpet
     4       Clarion             transmission from Great
 
Mechanical action throughout.
 
Compass: 58/32.

The stoplist and appeal leaflet appeared in 'The Organ Club Journal', May 1986. Since that time the old Harris/Bishop/Rothwell organ is still in situ and there have been no recent announcements about the progress of the appeal.




ST. MARTIN-IN-THE-FIELDS, TRAFALGAR SQUARE

Bevington installed a substantial instrument here in 1854; it was rebuilt by Hill in 1869 and 1912, and by Hill, Norman & Beard in about 1929. R. Spurnden Rutt & Co. Ltd. rebuilt it once more in 1935/6, leaving it with 90 stops on three manuals. (Click here to see the Bevington and Rutt stoplists.)

Paul Stubbings recalled in 1996:

By the 1970s the electrics became, in the words of a leading organ builder "a maze of fast-deteriorating cables, relays and multipoint switches... under some circumstances considered a fire-risk... of poor quality, much of it Post Office surplus". Visitors to the instrument have little difficulty in recalling all manner of sparks between the keys and the smell of burning rubber as the organ approached fortissimo.

At the end of the 1970s the church was considering a proposal for a new 39-stop organ by J.W. Walker & Sons. This came to nothing, but by 1985 an appeal was underway for a new organ by Frobenius. The proposed 43-stop instrument was to be as follows:


GREAT     
    16       Principal          
     8       Oktav
     8       Spidsfløjte
     4       Oktav
     4       Fløjte
    2 2/3    Quint
     2       Oktav
    1 3/5    Terts
     -       Mixtur
     8       Trompet
     4       Trompet
 
SWELL    
     8       Principal
     8       Viola di Gamba
     8       Celeste
     8       Rørfløjte
     4       Oktav
     4       Fløjte
    2 2/3    Quint
     2       Fløjte
    1 3/5    Terts
     -       Mixtur
    16       Fagot
     8       Trompet
     8       Oboe
             Tremulant
 
RÜCKPOSITIV
     8       Principal
     8       Gedakt
     4       Oktav
     4       Gemshorn
     2       Svegl
    1 1/3    Quint
     1       Sivfløjte
     -       Scharf
     8       Dulcian
             Tremulant
 
PEDAL
    16       Principal
    16       Subbas
     8       Oktav
     8       Gedakt
     4       Oktav
     -       Mixtur
    32       Fagot
    16       Basun
     8       Trompet
     4       Skalmej
 
5 unison couplers (no Swell to Rückpositiv).
 
Compass: 56/30.

This proposal came to nothing, and the church reverted to Walker as its builder of choice. Finally, in 1990, a new 48-stop Walker organ was installed.

(Paul Stubbings was quoted in 'The Organ' quarterly, Summer 1996; the Frobenius stoplist appeared in 'The Organ Club Journal', July 1985.)



Back to the index of organ proposals  |  Back to the index of organ designs & stoplists  |  Back to the front page